Carmella's is an absolute treasure. It doubles as a cozy, laid back establishment to eat an artfully crafted meal and also an classy spot to grab some delicious and unique cocktails. Everything that Carmella's does is put into action like the thoughtful brushstroke of practiced painter.
My choice of meal included the Southside, a cocktail that perfectly marries gin, cucumber and mint to create peak sipability. My entree was the Seared Scallops which included ricotta, flavorful and crispy mushrooms, and English pea risotto. All of the flavors came together as one to allow me to relish in every last bite. Our group also tried an array of appetizers including the Brussel Sprouts, Deviled Eggs, and the Crab and Avocado Dip. I could sing multiple praises for each. The brussels were crispy and flavorful, the deviled eggs were fried and served with a spicy sauce and the crab and avocado dip was addicting. I would recommend trying any of those three.
After I finished I said, and I quote, "I would invent a time machine right now just to go back to thirty minutes ago and eat that meal again." It was a truly fantastic.
The atmosphere is dimly lit and cozy which caters to an intimate evening. The decor is inviting and perfectly suited to the overall character of the space.
I cannot wait to frequent Carmella's time and time again. This has easily taken the top spot on my Pittsburgh favorites list.