I am a big fan of Mt Washington especially this area!
I have been to Harris Grill before and had a so-so experience but decided to give Shiloh a try because my dad had a Groupon.
Our server so comically bad but still managed to be charming in a stoner (why did I date this type of guy in high school) kinda way. He didn't really know anything about the menu but was very honest about his ignorance.
I was starving so I got a their veggie chili to hold me off until I demolish their turkey burger. Unfortunately all of our courses came out at once.
PRO: Awesome location, interesting menu (but it tries really hard to be funny), Outdoor seating, Solid turkey burger, Hearty Veggie Chili, free parking
CON: Completely out of it server, all of our courses came out at once, surprisingly pricey for causal dining,
OVERALL: Food is good but kinda pricey. Service is lacking. Might check out the bar situation next time (their happy hour specials looked promising)