Pretty good but not great. The staff is not very friendly and a tad awkward. I had two pieces of pizza (Rosa and Margherita) and it came to over 16 dollars. They were good and semi-unique (usually fresh pizza like this is thin crust instead of their thicker crusts), but not great and certainly not worth that money. If you are a pizza snob, you'll probably love it. I actually enjoy just regular pizza from the numerous, great local shops around Pittsburgh. Also, you can't just go in and buy bread any more. You have to preorder it and it can only be picked up on Thursday, so you have to have all your nice meals on Thursday night if you to have their fresh bread. And don't forget: cash only like its 1940 or something. This is a place that is definitely not worth the hype.