Atmosphere/vibe/decor is 5/5 no question. Not much of a fancy cocktail person so I just give a generic thumbs up because they have whiskey they can put over rocks for me. The pizza sadly is no better than a 3/5.
The magic number feels like 4 stars overall. With all that the Madison food scene has to offer, go to Lucille for drinks before/after dinner elsewhere. The greater point there being you should work in a stop at Lucille though. Cool spot.