I'm torn between 3 and 4 stars. While I loved the ambiance, and the service was great, I think I ordered the wrong thing. The muffalleta just left a lot to be desired. The meat wasn't sliced thin enough. The bread was not as good as the Italian bread that you get in New Orleans. And something just tasted off. Not terrible, but not what I expected.
That said, the Bloody Mary was fantastic, served with a sidecar of Abita Amber and a garnish of shrimp and oyster on the side.
I also tried a hush puppy happy hour app, which was delicious.
My dining companions loved their food.
If I were here again I would not order the same thing.
They do have some nice happy hour specials, but I wasn't into any of the drinks on happy hour special. I was tempted by the Pimm's Cup, but the description seemed a little off, as well.....not traditional. Everything else (non-happy hour) looked pretty good.
To sum it up: the Bloody Mary is where it's at. Get that.