I expected better from Liberetto's but, ended up for unsatisfied than anything. We ordered a couple of pizzas here about a year back while we were partying it up at Howl at the Moon. Pizza was good but, was not worth the $40 spent.
Now fast forward to last week, we've been thinking about getting Liberettos since they had a cheese pizza deal that day for $11. I've never walked in for pick up before, but I was kind of grossed out.. The pizzas in the display glass, the single slices for order, were so nasty and dry! It looked like they were just chilling outside for the last 6 hours. I would never buy those slices, go with a full pizza to ensure freshness if you really want to try Liberetto's. I only ate a slice, I wasn't pleased.
If you want awesome NY style pizza, try Benny Pennello's next to the Heist Brewery.. wayyy better quality and prices there. Cheers!