Take it from this NYC girl, this is TRUE NYC pizza: thin, crispy but foldable crust with really flavorful sauce and bubbly-melty cheese and just a tad bit of pizza grease dripping on to your paper plate. Actually it's been a while since I could get pizza this good (for this cheap!) even back home (NYC), because all the old pizza places I grew up on have been sold to a new generation of owners who don't make good pizza. But anyway, I've been coming here since this was Mamma Mia's. The pizza was awesome then, and it's just as great now. Pizza On 40th is #1 of my list of pizza places in the ENTIRE valley.