First, the good: The atmosphere and decor is amazing, it is a huge, beautiful old church and is just such a fun space to visit.
Next the not-quite-so-good: The beer is okay/average for local brewery swill, but considerably overpriced. We'd visit a lot more often and probably end up spending more overall if the beer prices weren't so outrageous.
And finally, the not-good: The food. Granted we only tried one item, but it was AWFUL. We ordered their basket of "homemade chips" and they were disgusting - cold, soggy spiral-sliced potatoes that were stale (not crispy) and congealed with grease. Inedible. The bartender said that they "make them fresh every day" - ours had apparently been made in the morning and had sat around in their own cold grease all day. We politely sent them back but the bartender didn't seem very happy about it and we spend the remainder of the visit wondering if we were going to have to argue with her about paying for them (as it turned out, we were not charged).
Final thoughts: it's a cool bar, but the novelty has worn off for us. Mediocre beer at inflated prices and terrible food.