Looks like I'm going to be the first one to leave an average review.
Everyone in Monticello raves about this place. And I don't really see why to be honest. The food is average and overpriced. It serves primarily sandwiches that are pretty ordinary. You'll pay $8-12 for sandwich, side, and drink. If you want pie, add on another few bucks.
I think it may be the ambience that draws people. It is right off the square in Monticello and definitely has a unique, homey 'feel.' Middle-aged women seem to flock to this place. So maybe I'm just their wrong clientele.
If you're a guy with a good appetite you'll do better heading to 3 Ravens or The Pub.
If you're a woman who loves ambience and sandwiches, you've found your place.