The cupcakes are okay. The favors sound fun and interesting, but are so-so.
The food here is great. I've been a few times for lunch and have been consistently pleased. They have great, hearty vegetarian selections, which isn't the easiest thing to come by in Madison (we still are in Wisconsin, after all). The veggie sausage option at breakfast is swell.
My fave so far is the portabella sandwich and the fiesta slaw. The chili is also great - mildly spicy and very hearty. My father, an avowed carnivore with blatant disrespect for my vegetarian ways, even likes the chili!
The acoustics are awful. It's impossible to hear your dining companions.