I've been here a fee times and it's probably my favorite spot to get food in Ohio city. Crop bistro is better, but pricey enough to be reserved for more special occasions.
I normally don't do aside dishes, but the sauteed mushrooms here are phenomenal. Do get them. The croque madam sandwich is awesome and huge, you can never go wrong putting an over easy egg on a sandwich in my book. The braised short ribs are tender and oh so tasty. The presentation here is probably the best I've ever seen for a restaurant that will feed you for under $20.
That said, there are a few warts. I was unimpressed with the pork tenderloin dish I had last time, and it seems like the more expensive the dish, the less food that it comes with. The sandwiches are huge servings, the braised ribs just right, and the duck and pork tenderloins required me to order a side dish or go hungry.
Overall, great place to get a bite in Ohio city