My husband and I so enjoyed our first experience at Michangelos on Valentine's day that we decided to celebrate our 10th weddding anniversary there in July. It was hands down the WORST dining experience that either of us has ever had (and there have been some doozies!) OK...my hubby made reservations for a Saturday night and made sure to tell the hostess that it was our 10th anniversary. We got there a few minutes early and were seated right away at a table in a corner...and then we waited...and waited...then a crabby guy gave us our fancy water...and we waited some more. Meanwhile we watched all of the tables around us get served and waited on. We had to get up and ask the hostess to have our server take our drink order. A few minutes after complaining a very frazzled server came to take our drink order. He apologized saying that they were short staffed and he was covering the patio and our dining area. The weird thing was that all of the tables around us were getting served and we were not. Odd. Anyway, I ordered the filet with mashed potatoes and my hubby had ravioli of some sort. It was completely forgettable. The steak was cooked well, but the potatoes tasted frozen...they just had an odd flavor. We complained about the food and the service and we got a frail apology from the server...he looked like he'd been hearing that all night. We did not order dessert. We left deflated and disappointed. It was almost enough to ruin our anniversary. We went to Carrabba's the next night and had a fabulous experience...great meal and service.
Bottom line...Michaelangelos was underwhelming for any amount of money, especially considering it was one of the most expensive meals we've ever had!
Based on our first experience here and all of the positive Yelp reviews, we are going to give Michaelangelos one more chance ...not sure when...