(4.5 stars, but that rates a full 5 for Pittsburgh - I'm still holding out for a mindblowingly incredible bakery here)
Can't believe I hadn't reviewed them - used to live 3 blocks away. I never picked up a bad loaf from them, and the selection was always good. Their bread's the best in town. (Sweets are good, too, but there's plenty of other places in town to get those.)
...Now if I could only get them to open a location Lawrenceville so I could have good bread in walking distance.