I've had good food here in Pittsburgh, but I've never had anything that made me realize what the term "mouth-watering" really meant... until going to Proper.
The first bite of my spinach ricotta dumpling appetizer LITERALLY made my mouth water, it was that good. The cucumber melon soup was a winner too, and managed to not only NOT remind me of shower gel, but also set off flavor fireworks in my mouth!
My friend got the infamous brick oven pizza, Finocchio I believe. If you have a passion for good pizza, and I mean authentic, fresh ingredient pizza, this spot is where it's at!