Four words : VEGAN CHOCOLATE ICE CREAM.
Seriously one of the best kept secrets in Cleveland. You don't have to be vegan to like this (I would know). I've turned my friends and family onto it as well and they usually make it one of the flavors in their cup. They usually have two vegan flavors on rotation and they seriously are the best dairy-free ice creams I've had. Honestly, they're better than most "normal" ice creams and is super velvety. Definitely take my word for it and try a spoonful next time you're in - even my disgruntle steelworkers like it. Okay, okay, I'll stop.
Other perks of Mitchell's, aside from the amazing ice cream, is that it's a prime example of a gorgeous local business. I love the aesthetics on the inside. It's in some old theater and you can look up and see the old wooden beams intersecting a giant glass wall that let's you watch the workers mix up batches of ice cream. I've watched them wash and prepare fresh strawberries which is so refreshing in a world full of artificial flavors.
I will say if you get the vegan chocolate grab a cup cause it's pretty melty and the servings are so big I usually take it home and stick it in the freezer.
If you're at the market or eating in Ohio City definitely swing by for a sweet treat!