To be honest I kind of thought the rusty nail would be a bit "rustler" but rusty is in name only. I came here for lunch and our sever was super awesome and very attentive. Never once did I have to go with out water (and usually that is a problem because I tend to down water like I just ran a marathon). The food was pretty good. They cooked my medium rare burger just they way I like it (aka they didn't over cook it). Also they have a good list of sides that you can do instead of fries. Try the tomato cucumber salad it's delish.
Nice atmosphere, good food and fantastic service. Good job!