I would almost go four stars because Il Fornello tolerated our large party remarkably well (it took a long time for everyone to settle down enough to put a dinner order in). Of course, when asked what the house Rose was, our server answered "pink".
. . . Which kind of just meant that we had to order it once we were done with the house white ($32, not terrible, not delicious).
The crust here is good enough that those who usually spurn the extra crust will dredge it in oil and vinegar. The toppings on the various pizzas we ordered were good quality but overpowering, had I sampled them with a dull smokers tongue they probably would have been most delicious.