When I lived on McCaul, I used to come here a lot. We'd always get the same stuff - bruchetta to start, pizza or panini as our meal, wine, and homemade tira misu to top it all off.
I always assumed everyone loved it here - I had no idea people found the service slow or the food not good. It's one of my fave pizza joints in the city! This is thin crust at its best. Crispy and yummy. And I've never found the service unbearably slow (and trust, i hate slow service), although, it is admittedly slower than some other places. But I like that you're not rushed when you're there!
DONT FORGET THE TIRA MISU.