I recently moved into the area and on the day we moved in I was looking for pizza delivery that was not your standard chain. After reading the review for Tony's and Nick's Place, I decided to give them a try. I called in the delivery request and was pleasantly surprised by how friendly and efficient the lady on the phone was. For our first order I got:
1 panzerotti
1 medium pizza
2 sandwiches (one veal and one steak)
1 salad
Delivery took about an hour - too long for me, but the food was tasty, so we let the long delivery time go. Folks were specially blown away by the panzerotti and the sandwiches. The pizza was meh - nothing special, and the salad was just a plain salad.
To-date we have ordered twice from here, and for our second order, we stuck to the panzerotti and sandwiches. I really like the veal sandwich, but it is a shame that by the time the food is delivered to you, the bread is pretty soggy and cold. Nevertheless, it's still pretty good.
If you are dining in, keep in mind that they have no seating.