Either I came on an off day or my expectations were just too high for this place. Ate here on a Friday night and the line wasn't bad, but it did take almost 20 minutes to get through the 10-15 people ahead of us. Some people say they liked the layout of this place, I didn't. All the people lining up for the crab legs block all the food right ahead of it, so you don't know whether to cut in front of them if you just want to grab something, or wait with everyone else even if you're not going for the crab legs.
The crab legs were pretty good. The oysters were not. The prime rib was good. The sushi not so much. The gelato was good. The other desserts not so much. Beware they have macaroons, not macarons. The veggie dishes were fresh. The shrimp cocktails were small and limpy. The unlimited beer and wine is a nice addition, but really are you going to fill yourself up with alcohol at a buffet?
This place is probably on par with Wynn and Bellagio, but at a lower price point, so that's a plus. I'm actually interested in trying their non-seafood buffet and seeing what kind of food you can get in that. Either way, I may need to give this place another shot as I was ever so slightly disappointed.