I grew up in Madison, so I've loved this stuff since I was a kid. This location is a weird kind of industrial place, but it still feels welcoming and get's the job done. Definitely go when you can tour the facility or sit outside!
My favorit flavors are White House (cherry vanilla), butter pecan, Mackinac Island Fudge (vanilla with swirls of thick fudge), and Grasshopper (mint with chocolate chips and marshmallow)
Very rich!
And nothing lives up to it...I've searched and searched!