If you rely solely on reviews you are doing yourself a disservice. Go out and live a little and even make up your own mind :)
If I didn't do that I would have really missed out. We went to the discount ticket place to pick up our Le Reve tickets and decided to also buy 25% off dinner at Dal Toro. We didn't do the research ahead of time but later read some reviews and were thinking twice.
However, we still went. Reservation was made for us at the discount ticket place on the strip and all we did was show up. I ordered the fetticcini bolognese (sp) - AMAZING!!!!! The last time I tasted authentic Italian food was in Germany (I know that sounds weird, but I lived there for 16 years and it's as close to Italy as I got). Honestly I can't stop thinking about this dish, it could have been shared BUT I choose to eat ALL OF IT.
My husband ordered something equally amazing. I can't remember the name but it had spaghetti and a lot of seafood.
We both are food stobs and thought the food was super good. The waiter was also wonderful. We would go there again and recommend it to anyone wanting good italian food. The car museum was always really neat to walk through afterwards (yes it was free).
Our bill came to 80 or so but we received the 25% discount on top of that....