Not to mirror Samantha's review but I'm also torn between 3 and 4 stars. It's so back and forth that I almost want to go with 3 --- but i really love going there --- so I'm going with four! I also agree with most points of her review. I've been to Felice three times. Once for a "date night" with my boyfriend where we sat at a table outside, and twice for drinks at the bar with him.
Both experiences at the bar were great. We had the same bartender both times and I totally forget her name (sorry!) but she has lots of tattoos and always is rocking a cool hairstyle. Regardless, she always takes the time to help us pick a wine that we can agree on or steer us a different direction so we will both be happy. She is prompt and attentive without being overbearing. Water glasses are always filled as were our drinks. If we wanted to have conversation she chatted with us and if not, she was not hovering over us. I've had great service and great experiences at the bar.
Now onto table service --- when we sat outside this summer and had a full dinner/drinks WHOA they missed. Everything took SO SO SO SO SO long. Another unintended 1.5-2 hour dining experience. I honestly forget what appetizers we had -- I recall them both being okay. When my boyfriend's drink was empty for ten minutes -- she asked if he wanted another one and did not acknowledge my empty glass. Brought him a refill (7 mins?) later and the acknowledged my empty wine glass. Another 10 mins to refill that one. It was a little excessive. We both got pasta dishes. Mine was not good. Not a lot of flavor but I ate it. His was really good. I believe it was the pene and I got spag. Or vice versa. I don't really remember. I mainly remember everything taking forever and not being really worth it.
Would I go back? Yes!!!! However, I will continue to sit at the bar and probably still just go there for the drinks.