I will be the first to admit that we went at a rather obscure time-- 2ish on a Wednesday afternoon, so the crowd wasn't really "hopping." I, by no means, would consider myself uber religious, but walking in and drinking beer in this old church felt a little...off-putting at first (and was then replaced with a tinge of awesome?). Beer and meal were OK. We had an order of pierogies for an appetizer, which was the highlight of my time there. The service was great. Overall, the experience was a C+-- I think I would be more inclined to try a new restaurant than come back, but certainly no one would have to twist my arm for a reappearance. I definitely think a fun crowd would make up for the shortcomings I found.