Prior to the renovations we were regular customers but since the renos we have been just 3 times and that's probably it.
Our dinner last Friday was tasty (except the Caesar salad) but not exceptionally so and the ambiance can be repeated several times over at most any local restaurant. The thing that will deter us is the price.
We have no objections to spending $100-$150.00 for dinner; we do that EVERY Friday night,. But you can get better and more consistent dinners at "The Keg" or "Gabriel's" ( the latter is just down the road). The Veal Parmigiana at Cagney's is double in price to anywhere.
While the old Cagney's needed a makeover the new Cagney's does as well.