I didn't come here expecting much, so I was pleasantly surprised with what I got!
Btw, I wasn't really disappointed w/the size of the milk bar bc I had checked out the Momofuku website prior to coming and understood it was gonna be a closet. Not a big deal to me.
I tried:
-compost cookies: really good!! I like how crispy mine was. The coffee part was kinda overbearing at times, but I like how the cookie wasn't overly sweet
-maple blueberry cookie: too sweet & mushy/soft for me, I won't get it again. I was so overwhelmed w/maple that I couldn't really remember the blueberry.
-birthday cake truffles: YUMMMMMM, but they're so sweet that you can only have one at a time. I say you split it w/2 friends so you guys can all enjoy just 1 truffle w/o feeling like you'll get diabetes
-strawberry lemon cake truffles: really good, as well!! Not as sweet as birthday cake truffles, so I think it's slightly better.
-crack pie: just like other yelpers have said, imagine eating a pecan pie w/o the pecans. Luckily, I like that, so I really enjoyed the crack pie!