Really not sure how this place had a 5-star score; either folks have low expectations for Indian in this part of town or we ordered on a bad night.
We ordered the three usual dishes we get at any Indian Restaurant:
Palak Paneer - The actual paneer was good but the sauce was just not good.
Butter Chicken - The sauce for this dish was actually excellent but the chicken terribly dry.
Lamb Korma - Relatively dry meat yet again; Korma sauce was ok
Saffron rice was exceedingly floral (might just be personal preference) and the Garlic Naan lacked any real garlic flavor.
I would suggest Tamarind if your in the Evanston area or Moti Mahal if your closer to the downtown core.