I would recommend a reservation.
I went there with Oystermania coupons on a date, and it was near perfect. The wine menu keeps it simple and affordable, the oysters were delicious, and everything I ate was pretty tasty.
Highlight goes to the truffle oil salmon tartare, it tasted like pure love, with caviar sprinkled on top.
My only slight critique regards the fish tacos, it's always better with marinated fish as opposed to fried stuff.
Our waiter was friendly and attentive, the space is small but comfy, the only thing I didn't like was the loud hockey game playing, but I have to disclose that: I'm a grumpy old man.