First things first, expect to take a doggie bag home because portion sizes here are HUGE.
I've been to Zappitelli's twice for a sit down meal and definitely was not disappointed either time. This past time I went with my family and ordered the potato gnocchi. I could only eat half of them because there were so many, but that was not for lack of trying :). If I had room I would have downed the whole plate.
Beer selection is ok, nothing spectacular.
My one complaint is that we were one of three families in the restaurant at the time, and they seated all of us right on top of each other. It would have been nice to have at least a table in between, especially when it wasn't that busy.