Four young professional adults + big appetites + The Ultimate & the Appetizer Sampler (fried shrimp, oysters, calamari, crawfish) = Big Ass Grins & Full stomachs. The Ultimate feeds about 3 people so that's why we got the sampler. Granted this was for lunchtime so we were satisfied but if you're hungry and it's dinnertime, consider getting more for a group of 4.
We didn't know which seasoning to do so we just did the homemade juicy which is all of them and it was pure heaven. Also, we all liked things spicy but with it being a hot day and the fact that we're about to smash a lot of food, I recommend doing the mild like we did so you can actually remember how it all tasted. Don't worry, you get a big and gloves but it's likely with the homemade juicy that you'll still get sticky fingers so I just deal with it :) Also, maybe think about wearing darker clothing and nothing too nice.
For what you get, the price point is also reasonable with everything round out to about 25-30/person with tip and a beer each. Such a solid place - thank you for bringing this to Cleveland!