Amalfi's has a very good New York style pizza. the rest of the menu is very predictable, and the items I've had have been delivered in a manner that matches my expectations for the price I'm paying. Most of my experiences are take out, although Joe and the staff have always seemed friendly to me.
Which is why I cannot understand the two very whiny notices printed and taped to the cash register instructing the customer how to behave.One was about not asking for a return after having taken out food days earlier, the other was equally petty. I do not understand why they choose to display their dirty laundry for all customers, but it definitely brings down the atmosphere and lowers the expectations of guests.
Good pizza, I hope they stay in business, and I hope they read this review.