I have been with National rental for last year and half. I m currently still in the middle of swithching 100% of my rental needs from Avis First to executive elite.
Being Avis first you are greated and treated like a king, someone sometimes turn of the car for you. (Sometimes) not with National.
Then again with being National you walk to the garage, pick any car you like in the executive elite isle, if nothing appeals talk to them to get cars from the vip.
At Cleveland airport, selection is not much, Altimas, 300s, new malibus and new fusions. I wish they have more. Then again my malibu's only have 300miles, brand new, new smell and new engine kinks.
Still a plus.