During my grad school days Hemingway's Cafe was a staple. My friends loved ordering the quirky 'buckets of shots' with names like, Lady GaGa and Taylor Swift. As someone over 30 I couldn't in good conscious order a pitcher of shots (without becoming ill from the insane amount of sugar and alcohol) but no worries, because "Hems" always has a great selection of beer on draft.
The grad school crew favorite was the pita chips and artichoke dip. Rich, creamy and full of fat. And delicious. The I-Need-To-Eat-Healthy version of myself loves the selection of wraps, with the hot honey wrap taking center stage. Instead of fries I always opt for mashed potatoes.
The wait staff here is great and have worked there for many years. They're friendly and go out of their way to make sure you're enjoying yourself and that your glass is never empty.
The atmosphere is pure college. Small booths and crowded throughways. So turn your nose down and enjoy it for what it is - a great college bar and restaurant.