So sad to say this, but things have changed here. Let me start off by saying we have loved this place for years and don't typically write negative reviews - especially for special local shops like this one with lots great folks behind them.
But the past 3 times we have encountered problems. Missing items, extremely burned toast, etc.
Today's example:
We always order the Yummy Yummy in my Tummy which on the menu explicitly states:
Yummy Yummy in My Tummy | 3.5
Warm Nutella + Fresh Bananas on Toasted Bread
Simple right?? Nutella, bananas, bread.
As you can see in our photo, they substituted the Nutella with peanut butter. (We weren't notified). Normally not a big deal, and we are pretty easy going - but this kind of stuff keeps happening and it's a bummer.