Finally tried Secret Pizza, and I loved it. I got a thick Sicilian slice, and it was great. It was so good that I got back in line and got another slice. And this was after already eating at Holstein's. Had my pizza and beer before seeing Neon Trees at the Boulevard pool. Only knock I have is that I have to get something like a Bud Light to drink with my pizza. Wish they had maybe one good local craft beer on draught, then it would be 5 stars.
Atmosphere, although small, is quite cool. I sat at an Arcade game and had my pizza and beer. Unfortunately the arcade game didn't work or I just couldn't figure out how to use it and so I wasted a dollar.