I live right next door to the place so I had to see what everyone was raving about.
I won't lie: can you find much better in Etobicoke? Yes. Absolutely.
The decor is very dated and the fake flowers are dusty and appear dirty. But for the most part, the place is fairly clean with plenty of seating in the two dining rooms.
Food-wise, I've had a few different pasta dishes and I question whether or not their Alfredo sauce is made from scratch. Tasted very much processed and therefore, I would not recommend it. I did however thoroughly enjoy the Bolognese sauce & angel hair pasta.
I continue to get each time the Antipasto plate... Thoroughly delicious! Each time, it is slightly different. The Mussels are excellent and great value for your money. The homemade Tiramisu is huge and a must have, even shared.
This is a neighbourhood restaurant that has been a staple for many. The old charm service makes it irresistible. I simply tell others: keep your expectations to a min-med level and you will not be disappointed.