Best meatballs in town.
I say that with the preface of lately Tony's has been very hit or miss. Sometimes they are amazing, other times they are ok. Their pizzas are huge. Like the box doesn't fit in the oven huge. And (we have tested this) the bigger the pizza, the better it tastes.
We have ordered pretty much everything on the menu, for dinner, for family functions, leaving Duckworths.... Normally we are very happy. Sometimes, we don't know where it went wrong. However, the good times outnumber the not-so-good times.
They have a frequent visitor card, where if you spend $100 on pizza (or buy 10 pizzas) your 11th is free. We've filled up quite a few cards.
Get the meatballs.