My husband and I booked our rehearsal dinner at Piccolo Forno, and we loved it! Nealey was so easy to work with, and helped us create the perfect evening. Everyone loved the food, and the rustic, beautiful upstairs private room. They are also BYOB which helped us save money. We hit one snag in the evening (there was a confusion on the menu, we had ordered 2 vegetarian dishes that were not served), and Nealey fixed the issue immediately and refunded us for a portion of the meal.
I would definitely recommend Piccolo Forno for a private event, but also for dinner in the city!