Eleven-- you are so extra, but I love you so. Out of all the new American places in Pittsburgh, Eleven is consistently the one I want to go to for all special occasions.
There's valet parking in the front. The restaurant inside always makes me feel like I'm in the Great Gatsby era--it's dark and there are amazing lights and the seats are so plush. But the real standout, and the reason I keep coming back is the food. Everything that I've had, from seafood, to steak, to pork chops, has been amazing. They also circle the tables with different bread options that are to die for.
The desserts are good too! Everything is good. Go make a reservation now.