I remember going through the church "shopping" experience two years ago before landing at New City. It can be scary to walk into a new place and it is doubly hard when you want to make connections quickly, but you are not finding the right fit.
New City Church is a warm, welcoming, and dare I say, fun church. If you are brand new to the church thing, you will not feel judged. If you are a spiritual old-timer, you will still be challenged. It's definitely worth a look.