Four stars for their macaroons! I wish I would have tried it before I left as I would have bought more! I got one of their seasonal pumpkin ones to-go and it was absolutely amazing.
I was however, a little disappointed in the club sandwich and potato salad. Nothing was terrible about either, but nothing about it stood out as tasty. Hopefully their other menu items are better.
Also, the atmosphere was not what I expected. I've been reading about this place for a long time and everyone seems to love it. But the inside and outside wasn't someplace I would choose to sit and catch up with friends.
I'm sure I will be back to try other flavors of their macaroons though!