We celebrated our anniversary at Gamekeepers because we had a great coupon deal for the restaurant. The menu had a wide range of choices including pastas, fish and meat - and offered "small" plates. I took advantage of the small plate entree so I could have an appetizer, salad and dessert! All were good - my meat was prepared rare when asked for medium, but I don't mind that much. The waitress comped our desserts - cheesecake and carrot cake for the mistake because I was almost done eating it when she noticed the kitchen's mistake.
Tastewise, nothing blew me out of the water but we had a nice atmosphere even when surrounded by large parties. Everyone seemed to know eachother - must be the Chagrin Falls representation Angry B mentioned :) The pace was nice and slow and we really enjoyed the experience.
We will go back for dinner again and will also sit outside on their large patio!