I absolutely love this place. It is located in the basement of a paint store on an obscure side road next to the Queensway. During my last visit, I ordered the butter chicken pie, mushroom pie and beef stew pie.
1) Butter Chicken - The filling was good and flavourful, however the chicken was a little dry
2) Mushroom - By far the best pie at the Pie Commission. Despite being a carnivore, this pie made me think twice.
3) Ground Beef - Good and standard pie
Key criteria of a good pie is the crust and it was not too soggy and had just the right amount of crisp to it.