I'd give it 5 stars if they could figure out how to make this place quieter. It doesn't matter how slow (or busy), whether you're in the bar or dining room - or even the semi-private dining area - this place can be deafening! You really have to focus on the conversation you're having at your table because you can hear everyone else's. I feel bad for the staff because you can tell they have a hard time as well.
We've been here for fish fry twice in the last few months and have had wonderful service and food both times. My husband likes that they have walleye as an option which he got both times. My mom's boyfriend enjoys the all-you-can-eat fish and chicken option. The prices are very fair and the portions are spot on. Even though the place was packed both times (came around 5p one time, 7:30p the second time), the service was quick and the food came out in a decent amount of time.
Rodeside can hold a lot of people so don't be put off by the parking lot if it's full. They have some arcade games and pull tabs if you need to entertain yourself during a wait =)