This review is a toughy...I'd give them a 3 for coffee and a 5 for service. The owner and barista were a blast to talk to, and they were happy to show us all sorts of cool coffee gear and the miscellaneous stuff the owner fiddles with in the back. That was a lot of fun.
Unfortunately their coffee isn't great. Not that bad, and maybe the coffee beans themselves are well-roasted, but my espresso and the espresso-based drinks just didn't cut it, so a 3.