Took my wife to Otto's for our anniversary prior to seeing Rock of Ages. Started with a 3 cheese sample, olives, and 2 carnes. The cheeses came with dipping sauces - like honey and black truffle oil. The cheeses, olives, and carne were great. For dinner my wife had the quatro fomagi pizza and I had the lamb meatballs. The pizza was wood fired and the crust was thin and crispy. Very favorable sauce and cheeses. The meatballs were great - tender and full of flavor.
Otto's has an extensive wine list and the waiter was glad to help pair up wine with our appetizers and dinner. Service was great and attentive the whole dinner.
Otto's is expensive, portions are not large, but the quality and flavor surpass both of those issues. I would have given Otto's 5 stars but our only complaint was a few minutes after getting our cheese and carne our dinner came. I would have been great to sit and enjoy our appetizer with our rushing it.