I'm torn here. Their tap selections are solid and I had their burger at last year's Pittsburgher Competition and loved it. This review is for their bar, not food, though.
I asked if the beer I wanted (8.2% ABV) came in a pint or chalice. I was purely curious about that because I've seen different places have different benchmarks for a "big beer." Our bartender must have overheard me saying to my boyfriend that I always feel like I'm not getting my money's worth with a chalice because visually it's just smaller. She started talking about how she purchased a beer at another restaurant and it was more expensive than what Urban Tap would have priced it at and how it was a rip-off (she was talking about the same restaurant I work for, actually). This is a case of "Don't run your mouth if you don't know who you're talking to."
She did offer samples of the beers I was torn between and she was assisting the couple next to us with suggestions. So I'm trying to stay impartial in regards to her comments, though if you're reviewing the experience, that was part of the experience and it wasn't cool.
The other bartender seemed chill and like he had a good rapport with the customers. The price here was on the high end of average for Pittsburgh: $6 for a beer (good Lord, when did $6 for beer become acceptable) so I don't know where she had room to act like they have the best prices around. I'd love to come back and try the food - perhaps it'll be worth another star.