Was hoping Nick's would break the streak of mediocrity I've tasted since moving to the area. Menu looked great, reviews looked great, and prices were high enough that I thought it must be a diamond in the rough. And then...underwhelmed.
If you're seared at a regular table without an overhead light, download a flashlight app. Ambience is one thing, but I could barely read the menu.
Selections seemed to be on point but the food didn't follow through. I couldn't believe the portion size of my (slightly overcooked) salmon for the price. I've gotten more salmon on a salad.
I don't mean to say the place is a waste of time; it's just not worth $20-$30/plate. I enjoyed the location, and service was adequate, but I expect more from somewhere that charges that much.
Again, in a word: underwhelmed.