You can always count on their bagels to be fresh and delicious. I check in from time to time and the food is always consistently good. I usually get a bagel with either butter or cream cheese if I'm planning on working out later in the day.
I've never tried the Italian sandwich for lunch but I heard it's crazy good. I like the deli atmosphere and the regulars that frequent the bagel bin as well as the people behind the counter, they are really friendly and the other main reason customers keep coming back. If this is your first time here be prepared to be called baby or sweetie, a little southern charm to a New York business