This restaurant was recommended to us through friends and has a great reputation. We are new residents of Sun Prairie and have been searching for a good fish fry in this town. Due to popularity we arrived at an early dining hour for us - 5 pm. Good thing because within 20 minutes I overheard the hostess informing people it would be a 45 minute wait for a table. We enjoyed prompt service. Ordered draft beers, which were under $5 each. We ordered the broiled cod fish fry special, which comes with cole slaw and cheesy hash browns. The food was good, but not so amazing that I am willing to fight a crowd for it. We were seated at a high table near the hostess station, which was entertaining. While our server assured us "no rush" in finishing our drinks or paying the bill, the hostess was informing a party of 4 "that is your table is soon as they leave". We were rushed out. We will come back some time when it is a bit more low key. I don't understand 1) why people carryout from here - this is expensive takeout food, and 2) why people bring small children here - they would be very bored and out of place.
If you are coming here on a Friday or Saturday night, have a reservation or pack your patience for a long wait time.
We continue our search for our "every week" place in Sun Prairie. This isn't it.